How to choose a YouTube producer: 10 questions to ask before you pay
I see a lot of channels that come to me after another provider. Usually the previous producer wasn't bad. The client just didn't know what to ask and bought the wrong service.
1. Which channels have you run, and what changed in the numbers?
Not "who have you worked with" but before and after. For example, a monobank co-founder's channel I ran went from 6,000 to 60,000 subscribers in three years. The starting number matters, because growing from zero and from 500K are different jobs.
2. What did those views do for the business?
For a business channel, a million views with no leads is worse than 10,000 views with three clients. Ask about leads, sales and recognition.
3. Have you run your own channel?
Not required, but a strong signal. Someone who took their own channel from zero knows what it feels like when a video flops three weeks in a row.
4. How will you choose topics?
Good answer: from search demand, your analytics and competitors. Weak answer: "we'll come up with creative ideas."
5. Who does thumbnails and titles?
They decide whether people click. If the answer is "the designer handles it" with no word about CTR, be careful.
6. How do you work on retention?
Ask them to walk you through a real retention graph and explain where viewers leave and why.
7. Will you use ads or fake views?
Honest answer: fake views never, ads only in-feed and only where they help YouTube find a narrow audience.
8. How much of my time will this take?
Realistically, one filming day a month or 2 to 3 hours a week if you're the face of the channel.
9. What's in the monthly report?
At minimum: CTR, retention, new subscribers, returning viewers, best and worst videos, and the plan.
10. What happens if there are no results after three months?
A good producer tells you which numbers show the strategy is working and what they'll change if those numbers don't appear.
Red flags
- A guaranteed number of subscribers or views
- Prices several times below market
- No case study with numbers
- Asking for owner access instead of manager access
- A first call that's only about packages, not your business
Feel free to ask me all ten. Book a call.