YouTube producer vs agency: which should you hire?
Your company has decided to do YouTube. The first question is who runs it. There are four options.
| Producer | Agency | Freelancer | In-house | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who owns strategy | The producer | Account lead + strategist | Usually nobody | Your marketer |
| Monthly cost | $1,200–2,500 + production | $2,500–15,000+ | $300–1,500 | 2–4 salaries |
| Time to start | 1–2 weeks | 1–2 weeks | fast | 1–3 months to hire |
| Personal attention | high | depends on your size | high but narrow | full |
| Risk | depends on one person | a junior may run your account | no strategy | mistakes while learning |
When to choose an agency
When you need lots of videos, several channels, vertical content for every platform and an account manager compiling reports. The downside: the person who sold you and the person running your channel are often different people.
When to choose an independent producer
When the channel is built around a person: a founder, CEO or expert. A good producer assembles a team per project, so production capacity matches an agency, but strategy stays with someone senior. That's how I work: 1 to 2 new clients a month.
When a freelancer is enough
When you already have a strategy and need hands: editing, thumbnails, publishing.
When to build in-house
When YouTube is your main sales channel for years ahead. A common compromise: an outside producer runs the first 3 to 6 months while training your team, then the team takes over with monthly reviews.
See also what YouTube channel management costs.